--- git diff --stat (/home/claude-agent/forge-build/forge-assets/.forge-worktrees/1791828243-db5b51) ---
(no changes)
{"type": "result", "is_error": false, "result": "**Verdict: REVISE.** I read all eight images. Four findings follow.\n\n**F1 \u2013 Rafts: the three sizes aren't distinct enough (REVISE)**\n- Evidence: `lineup.png`, tiles raft-2, raft-3 and raft-4.\n- Symptom: raft-3 and raft-4 are narrow strips with the same plank colour and the same coil mark. At game scale they read as one object stretched, not three rafts.\n- Fix: vary the plank count, give each a distinct end detail, and add a rope or post accent.\n- Acceptance: at 55\u00b0 and 128 px tile size, a viewer can tell the 4, 6 and 8 m rafts apart without labels. Plank width reads as at least 4 px.\n\n**F2 \u2013 Tram and sweeper: identity colour is weak and the silhouette is thin (REVISE)**\n- Evidence: `tram.png` (whole body); `lineup.png` (tram tile).\n- Symptom:\n  - Cream and teal are present, but the teal is desaturated and sits on a grey-teal ground. Contrast is low.\n  - Body is a plain box with low-contrast windows, and the articulation joint is a dark band.\n  - At 16 m the model is a thin sliver.\n- Fix:\n  - Saturate the teal.\n  - Add a stronger cream roofline or stripe.\n  - Make the window band darker.\n  - Make the joint bellows more visible.\n- Acceptance: the tram's body-to-ground luminance contrast is at least 1.5:1 on the mid-grey ground, and the articulation is visible at 128 px.\n\n**F3 \u2013 Sweeper: brushes are barely readable (REVISE)**\n- Evidence: `street-sweeper.png`, the front-right wheel area at the bottom.\n- Symptom:\n  - The brushes are the key feature, but the orange brush is hidden behind and under the front wheel and the black bumper.\n  - From game view the truck reads as a plain orange box truck.\n  - The cab roof and rear box are flat orange.\n- Fix:\n  - Extend the brushes outward beyond the wheel line, with a dark bristle colour.\n  - Add a hopper or hose detail on the rear.\n- Acceptance: at 55\u00b0, two distinct dark bristle discs are visible outside the wheel silhouette.\n\n**F4 \u2013 Hedge: leaf texture is noisy and the shape is lumpy (REVISE)**\n- Evidence: `hedge.png`, the whole top and front faces; the baseline comparison is not needed.\n- Symptom:\n  - Scattered diamond leaf cards read as confetti or noise, not trimmed foliage.\n  - The body is uneven, with a bulge on the left edge, so it doesn't look like a trimmed hedge.\n  - The kerb is fine.\n- Fix:\n  - Cut the leaf-card count or size, or fold the pattern into the albedo.\n  - Even out the silhouette so the faces are flatter and the corners rounder.\n- Acceptance: at 128 px the top face reads as a uniform green with no isolated bright specks. The silhouette deviates less than 5% from a rounded box.\n\n**Passing (no finding):**\n- Bench: green frame, wood slats and armrests are clear and toy-like (`bench-side.png`, `lineup.png`).\n- Donut: pink icing, sprinkles and a brown base are clear and readable (`donut-side.png`).\n- Lily pad: the notch and pink flower are clear (`lineup.png`).\n- Tram signal: twin red lamps read clearly (`tram-signal.png`). The pole is thin but acceptable.\n\nI did not check runtime FPS or material parity. I did not flag the ground clipping or the donut framing, which are already scheduled.", "modelUsage": {"claude-sonnet-5-5": {"inputTokens": 4, "outputTokens": 1909, "cacheReadInputTokens": 29603, "cacheCreationInputTokens": 28669, "webSearchRequests": 0, "costUSD": 0.0937308, "contextWindow": 1000000, "maxOutputTokens": 128000, "thinkingTokens": 0, "canonicalModel": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "provider": "firstParty", "costBasis": "list"}}, "session_id": "6cbb8eae-9bb4-4b0b-9afc-6cd1ca908361", "worktree": "/home/claude-agent/forge-build/forge-assets/.forge-worktrees/1791828243-db5b51", "branch": "task/1791828243-db5b51", "items": {"num_turns": 9, "subtype": "success"}}