### Image descriptions

- **renders/thatch_ridge.png**: Curved thatch ridge cap with directional grey-brown reed striping, cut-reed cross-section on the end, and three visible dark curved hazel binding straps clamped over the top.
- **renders/thatch_panel.png**: Thatch roof panel with directional reed texturing, stepped bundle serrations along the eave, and cut-stem circle patterns across the thick exposed cross-sections.
- **runtime_assembly_cottage.png**: Full runtime cottage scene with active textures (stone, cream plaster, dark timber framing, textured thatch roof, red dormer tiles). The UI shows a "Clay" toggle button, confirming the current view is textured mode, not clay.
- **renders/sign_boot.png**: Hanging metal bracket holding a brown boot silhouette without a backboard. It has thin wooden battens pinned across the top cuff and bottom edge, but no lighter-colored sole.
- **details_thatch_grid.png**: Half-textured, half-unlit split diagnostic view showing the cottage thatch geometry and material mapping.

---

### Verification of previous critic claims

| Prior claim | Pixel evidence | Fact check |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Ridge has no bindings | Three distinct 3D binding straps wrap across the ridge in both `thatch_ridge.png` and `runtime_assembly_cottage.png`. | **FALSE** |
| Runtime image was clay | Full PBR materials are visible (timber, plaster, reed, stone). The UI button reads "Clay" as a toggle target. | **FALSE** |

---

### Requirements check

- **Passed**:
  - Directional grey-brown reed thatch.
  - Hazel bindings physically modeled on the roof ridge.
  - Thick cut-stem eave cross-sections with circular reed textures.
  - Board-free hanging boot sign (no rectangular backing plate).
- **Substantive findings**:
  1. **Boot lacks lighter sole**: The boot body is uniform reddish-brown; there is no contrasting lighter leather layer on the bottom tread.
  2. **Stray batten strips on boot**: Thin mounting strips run along the boot cuff and sole edge instead of a clean standalone cut boot.
  3. **Thatch panel bundling is uniform**: Bundles use regular triangular pitch waves rather than organic, irregular clump variation.

---

### Verdict

**REVISE** (boot requires lighter sole texture/geometry and removal of edge battens; thatch meets core structural and binding requirements).