**Verdict: thatch REVISE, boot PASS.** The attached image has no file path, so I did not cite it. Send its path if you want it checked.

Opened: `revision_2_before/details_thatch_grid.png`, `details_thatch_grid.png`, `renders/thatch_panel.png`, `renders/thatch_ridge.png`, `renders/sign_boot.png`, `test_house.png`, `runtime_assembly_cottage.png`.

**Before vs current:** the old roof was smooth beige. The current roof is grey-brown with fine strands running down the slope. That is a real improvement.

**Thatch: three remaining issues**
1. **Ridge has no hazel binding lines.** `thatch_ridge.png` shows a wavy top with no visible binding bands.
2. **Eaves are not shaggy.** The eave edge is a thin, regular sawtooth. Cut stem ends are barely readable, and the eave is not thick.
3. **Surface reads as striped wood or corrugated sheet.** Strands are long, straight and evenly spaced, with little bundle irregularity.

**Limits of this review**
- `runtime_assembly_cottage.png` shows the roof in clay mode, so it does not verify the thatch material in the runtime.
- The images cannot confirm the 300-triangle limit per thatch atom. The runtime figure (21,548 triangles) is for the whole assembly.

**Boot: PASS.** `renders/sign_boot.png` shows a board-free brown leather boot with a lighter sole band. Suggestion only: the rust-red tone could go a little darker to read as leather.